Questions for Darwin's "On the Races of Man" from The Descent of Man
What rhetorical strategy does Darwin employ in order to present and
refute counter-arguments regarding the significance of racial differences
for classification purposes?
Because Darwin looks at both sides of the argument regarding racial
difference from a seemingly objective point of view, his argument may appear
impartial. Do you think he has an opinion on the question of race
as it applies or doesn't apply to humans? If so, how does he convey
it?
Look at Paragraph 2 on p. 41 (in the reader; p. 62 in the original text),
which begins, "But the most weighty of all the arguments against treating
the races of man as distinct species . . . " What's Darwin's point
in this paragraph?
According to Darwin, how many different races are there?
What is Darwin's conclusion regarding the terms "race" and "species"
as they apply to humans?
What does Darwin mean when he says that humans are polymorphic?
Does he say or imply that non-white races are inferior? Where?
How might we reconcile his apparently racist language and/or statements
with other his apparently anti-racist language and/or arguments?
What's his overall thesis in this chapter?
In paragraph two of the excerpt from The Voyage of the Beagle,
note that Darwin moves from a general indictment of slavery to a direct
challenge to his readers to sympathize and identify with slavery’s victims.
What response does this aim to elicit from the predominantly Anglo audience?