Inventing Ireland:
Modern Irish Literature and

Cultural Identity

HON 394
Fall 2007


Dr. Jacquie Scott      Jacquie.Scott@asu.edu   

Tuesdays 3:30 - 6:15 p.m.   

Best 121   
     
   
  

Irish stamp commemorating Cuchulain


Irish A-208

(480) 965-6780

Office Hours:

T     2:30-3:00 p.m. &

       6:15 - 6:45 p.m.

W   10:00 - 12:00

       & by appt.

Last updated 30 October 2007

 

Schedule of Classes

This Daily Schedule Is Subject to Change; Any Changes Will Be Announced in Class and Posted Here.

 

  
Sept. 11 Colonial Ireland
 

Swift, "A Modest Proposal"
        Background & Focus Questions for "A Modest Proposal"

O'Connell, "Lament for Art O'Leary" (handout)

Apes & Angels (handout);

Focus Question: Analyze the propaganda in the images.  If you were English and hadn’t seen any Irish people, what would these images lead you to believe about them?

Research "Wiki" Entry due to the discussion board before class.  Be prepared to explain your topic and its relevance to Irish history (and today's readings, if applicable) to the class.

   
Sept. 14

THE FLIGHT OF EARLS

ICC Historian, Sean Prior, will present the story of The Flight of Earls on Friday, September 14, at 7:30 PM at the Irish Cultural Center. 2007 marks the 400th anniversary of the pivotal moment in Irish history which was the end of the ancient Gaelic Order that had existed in Ireland for over 1000 years. The cost is $5.00.

   
   
Sept. 18 Imagining a Modern Irish Identity


O’Leary, “The Hunger” (handout); Davis, “A Nation Once Again”; Mangan, “Dark Rosaleen”; “Roisin Dubh/Little Black Rose” (Kinsella translation, handout).  Hyde,  “Necessity for De-Anglicizing Ireland” (handout); Moran, “The Battle of Two Civilizations” (handout). 

Focus Questions:
  • Think about the ways that "A Nation Once Again," "Dark Rosaleen," and "Little Black Rose" imagine or represent Ireland as a non-colonial entity.  Who do the texts blame for Ireland’s woes?  Do they focus on the causes that had left Ireland with a self-image of victimized failure, or do they go further and imagine a positive modern Irish identity to replace colonial stereotypes?
  • What's Moran's thesis in “The Battle of Two Civilizations”?  Who does he hold responsible for the decay of Irish civilization?  
  • How do Hyde and Moran view "West Britonism"?
  • Compare the lyric "Little Black Rose" with the more modern “Dark Rosaleen.”  What similarities and differences are significant in terms of national identity-building?
  • In “The Necessity for De-Anglicizing Ireland,” who does Hyde hold responsible for  the decay of Irish culture and language? According to Hyde, why did people abandon Irish?
   

Sept. 21

Sept. 21: Third Friday Celi

   
   

Sept. 25


Gregory, Our Irish Theatre (MID 377-386); “The Rising of the Moon” (MID 54-62); Yeats, Cathleen Ni Houlihan (3-11); Yeats, On Bailes’ Strand (MID 12-32), Synge, Riders to the Sea (MID 63-72)

Focus Questions:

  1. Our Irish Theatre: How do the goals of the Irish theatre and the obstacles the founders encountered connect to other discussions we've had about Irish identity to date? 
  2. Rising of the Moon: Identify the conflict dramatized in this play.  Is this conflict resolved by the end of the play?
  3. Cathleen Ni Houlihan: identify and analyze the political metaphors and symbolic language that informs this play.  Do you think that Yeats is inciting young Irish males to violent rebellion?
  4. On Bailes' Strand: How does Yeats revise the Tain prestory we read ("The Death of Cuchulainn's One Son") to emphasize conflicts such as duty vs. desire, community loyalty vs. individual freedom?  Does the play take a pro-nationalist stance, or do you see it as more ambiguous?
  5. Riders to the Sea: Does this play dramatize a conflict between Christianity and ancient, pagan beliefs?  If so, how?  Is one religious view shown as more powerful than the other?
     


   

October 2

Shaw, John Bull’s Other Island (MID)



   

October 9

Synge, Playboy of the Western World (MID)


Annotated Bibliography due.

Focus Questions:

  • In his Preface to The Playboy of the Western World, JM Synge writes that “on the stage, one must have reality, and one must have joy.”  The reality in this play comes from the account Synge heard, when in the Aran Islands, about a man who “killed his father with the blow of a spade when he was in passion, and then fled to this island and threw himself on the mercy of some of the natives with whom he was said to be related.”  Which other realistic elements inform this play?  And what creates the joy Synge believed to be crucial for the stage?
  • Why do the townspeople accept Christy Mahon after he reveals that he has killed his father?
  • Christy tells the story of his father’s murder several times.  Carefully read the multiple narratives of that murder.  How does Christy change his story, and what effect does it have on his audience?
  • The townspeople treat Christy as a hero.  Is he heroic? 
   
October 13 Ceilidance workshops at the Center are on the second Saturday of the month from 1:00-3:00 PM. These are two hour dance intensive for beginning and advanced dancers. Beginners will focus on basic footwork and simpler Ceili dances (Fairy Reel, Siege of Ennis, etc). Advanced dancers will learn more difficult figure dances (Cross Reel, Trip To The Cottage, etc). If you are an expereinced Ceili go-er or if you have never danced before, this is the class for you! Make new friends and learn how to dazzle the spectators at the next ICC Ceili. Admission is $16.00 for adults and kids under 12 $2.00 Dates for the Ceili workshops for 2007 are October 13, November 10, December 8 For further information, please call (602) 258-0109.
   



The “Irishry” have preserved their ancient “deposit” through wars which, during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, became wars of extermination.  No people, Lecky said at the opening of his Ireland in the Eighteenth Century, have undergone greater persecution, nor did that persecution altogether cease up to our own day.  No people hate as we do in whom that past is always alive, there are moments when hatred poisons my life. . . .Then I remind myself that though mine is the first English marriage I know of in the direct line, all my family names are English, and that I owe my soul to Shakespeare, to Spenser, and to Blake, perhaps also to William Morris, and to the English language in which I think, speak, and write, that everything I love has come to me through English; my hatred tortures me with love, my love with hate.   

                                            –W.B. Yeats, “A General Introduction for my Work”

   

October 16

Yeats, "The Fisherman," "September 1913"; "Easter 1916"; "The Circus Animals' Desertion" (handout);  Pearse, “I am Ireland,” “Ideal, or Renunciation,” “The Rebel”; “Proclamation of the Irish Republic”; Stephens, selections from The Insurrection in Dublin.   Pearse & Yeats Focus Questions.
   
   

October 23

Moore, “Homesickness” (handout); Joyce, selections from Dubliners and Ulysses:

  • "The Dead" ("The Dead" is the final story in Joyce's short story collection Dubliners.) Print out this story and read it carefully.
  • Telemachus.” This is the opening episode of Ulysses.  It focuses on the young teacher Stephen Dedalus who has recently returned to Dublin after leaving it for Paris at the end of  Joyce's novel A Portrait of the Artist as a Young ManPlease print this episode out. 
  • "Calypso."  This is the fourth episode, which introduces us to Mr. Leopold Bloom, Jewish ad salesman and "Odysseus" character who wanders around Dublin  on June 16, 1904.  Look it over, but you don't need to print this out.
  • "Penelope."  This is the final episode, which occurs in Molly Bloom's mind.  Check it out, but you don't need to print it out.


Focus questions for "The Dead":

  • How would you describe Gabriel Conroy?  Find several places in the text where his character is revealed through exposition (description) and action/dialogue.  Does his character change after his "epiphany" (sudden revelation)?
  • Pay close attention to the character of Freddy Malins.  How is he represented?  Beyond comic relief, what is his function in the story?
  • Who narrates this story?  Is s/he reliable?
  • Pay attention to the references to political figures important to Irish history.  What are Gabriel's attitudes toward them?
  • Much critical attention has been focused on the story's ambiguous ending.  Based upon evidence in the text, do you think Gabriel achieves "heroic" transcendence and a new level of self-knowledge as he transcends his material circumstances, or does his swoon indicate a bow to the inevitable paralysis resulting from his own inadequacy and the sterile world into which he has been acculturated?

Focus Questions for "Homesickness":

  • Which assumptions about America influence the way that the people of Bryden's native village treat him when he goes back to Ireland?
  • He seems to prefer his life in America.  Why?  Is it as idyllic as his Irish friends assume?
  • He has an opportunity to take Margaret to America with him.  Why does he make the choice that he does?

 
   

October 30

Modern Irish Identity


Keane, The Field

   

 

November 6

Sheridan, The Field





November 13

Research at Irish Cultural Center must be completed by this date.  Heaney, "Punishment" (handout) & "Casualty" (web).



  Nov. 17: third Friday Celi



November 20


McCourt, Angela’s Ashes.

Focus questions (for both week's discussion):

  • On the first page, McCourt sets up several Irish stereotypes--"the shiftless loquacious alcoholic father; the pious defeated mother moaning by the fire; pompous priests; bullying schoolmasters," etc.--and his memooir does introduce several characters to whom these stereotypes would seem to apply.  However, the story eventually complicates, revises, or shatters these stereotypes.  How does he achieve this?
  • How does the Cuchulain myth shape or reflect Fank McCourt's emerging identity?  Why does he display such unusual possessiveness about Cuchulain stories?
  • Apart from Cuchulain, who are Frank's other role models?  How do they affect his childhood identity?
  • Why did Frank's mother and father both treasure Margaret so much more than any of the boys?  Do they have different reasons? 
  • As always, bring in your own questions.
   
   
November 27


Finish Angela’s Ashes.

  • Consider the complex characterization of Frank's father.  His alcoholism deeply affects the physical and emotional wellbeing of his family, yet Frank often portrays him as gentler and more nurturing than Frank's mother.  Also, we learn that he has the ability to stop drinking when adequately motivated, as he maintains two sober periods in the text.  Given this, apart from physical addiction, why does his father get drunk?  What psychic need does it fulfill, if any?
  • Practically from birth, Frank is labelled as having his father's dark looks and "odd" manner (note how often this is contrasted to his brothe Malachy's bright, charming smile and blond curls), which in some sense marks him as one who all expect to follow in his father's footsteps--hardly an optimistic future.  How does Frank escape this path?
  • The reader quickly realizes that the title refers to the author's mother, Angela.  But how are we to understand the second word in the title; that is, what are Angela's ashes?  What do they represent?


Dec. 4
Modern Irish Identity

Dec. 7

Final Projects due by 3:00 p.m.


 

   
August 21 Introduction to class. 
  On Thursday, August 23rd, your first blackboard post is due by 10:00 p.m.  Introduce yourself to the class and indicate in your message that you accept the  Seminar Participation Guidelines.
   
   
August 28 Ancient Ireland
 

Tain—Prestories 1-50; Smedley, from Race in North America (handout)

Focus Question: National epics such as The Tain reflect the values important to a culture's identity, so as you read the "Prestories" that set out the background for the Tain Bo Cuailgne (Cattle Raid of Cooley), identify the qualities or things you think this ancient culture values.  You might also consider what it devalues.  How do these things relate to modern America's self-image?
   
   

Sept. 4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Tain 52-253

Focus Questions:

    1. How does the heroic code work?  What are the rules of combat, if any?  Who respects them, who breaks them? 
    2. The “Combat of Ferdia & Cuchulainn” chapter is considered by many to be the heart of The Tain.  Read this chapter carefully and prepare to discuss why you think Cuchulainn and Ferdia make the choices that they do.  What do you consider to be the most significant aspects of the human condition illustrated in this section of the narrative?   
    3. Think about representations of gender and power in The Táin. From which roles are characters excluded due to their gender?  For which characteristics or behaviors are they valued? 

Reading Response Prompt:  Choose one of the questions above, then post your response to the discussion board before class today. 

You may find this supplementary material interesting:

http://vassun.vassar.edu/~sttaylor/Cooley/Names.html

Optional reading:  Lady Gregory's translation of The Death of Cuchulainn