Home | Course Policies | Daily Schedule | Assignments | Links

English 101
Bruce Matsunaga
Peer Review: Evaluation and Analysis

1. Does the author successfully illustrate how the physical space is shaped by the people who use it? Are the author's conclusions supported by evidence (descriptive or interpretive)?

2. What cultural need does this space fulfill? Does the author explain this relationship between people and the public space? Is the author's explanation supported by evidence?

3. As a reader, does this space sound appealing? Why or why not?

4. Does the author attempt to explain how different people view the space? Does the author adequately probe different viewpoints?

5. Given the author's analysis notes, can you brainstorm a list of people who would be allowed in the space and people who would be excluded? If you can, then do so. If you cannot, let the author know what kinds of information he/she needs to add.