Author_________________________
Peer Editor_____________________
1) Does the thesis announce what the author will discuss?______What does the author say s/he will discuss?____________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
2) Does the author discuss hir strengths and weaknesses? What does the author identify as strengths?_________________________________________________
Weaknesses?________________________________________________________
Does the author give examples of strength and weakness from WP1 & 2?
What examples does the author give? Please list
3) What kinds of rhetorical knowledge does the author
discuss?
4) How does the author show that s/he is meeting the goals
set out in the outcomes statement?
5) Does the author seems comfortable using rhetorical
terms? Please give several examples.
6) Does the author's conclusion make a statement about
hir rhetorical progress?___
7) In a two paragraph closed form essay comment on whether or not you agree with the author's estimation of hir writing progress, and why.