Hinduism or Animism?
Balinese Wayang Kulit Theater

By Juiching Wang, 

School of Music Arizona State University

Introduction Wayang Kulit Ways of Seeking Gods Conclusion

Introduction

In ancient time, a King of Java, angry with a disobedient son, decided to send him into exile. He took him to the south part of the kingdom, and told this son to depart forever. When the boy had vanished over the horizon, his father drew a line in the earth with his finger to mark the frontier separating them. The waters of the Java Sea and Indian Ocean joined there, and the island of Bali was born.                                                                                                                                                                        Panthou 1978

 

Geographically speaking, this legend has its truth because Bali and Java, separated by a three-kilometer strait today, used to form one land. This “chosen land of the gods”(Panthou1978: 4), approximately 300 square kilometers with a population of about two million, is east of Java in the Indonesian archipelago (Ornstein 1980: 179).

Tied to Java closely since the ancient time, the most important cultural influence of the Balinese therefore came from the Javanese whose culture had been thoroughly penetrated by Indian religious thoughts (Ornstein 1980:179). Hindu-Buddhist character was imported to the island of Bali when the Islamic powers began to invade Java. It was during the year of 1450 that the proud kingdom of Java, the Majapahit dynasty, collapsed. Members of the Hindu-Javanese nobility, artists, and priests gradually fled to Bali. From then on, the island of Bali became the refuge for their religious beliefs, and had reserved most significant features inherited from East Java. According to Miettinen, “contacts with Islamic Java were few,” therefore “Balinese culture was able to develop its intrinsic features” without being disturbed by outside influences (Miettinen 1992: 110).

Although being influenced by the Hindu-Buddhist beliefs to a great extent, Balinese culture has rooted their religious philosophy in animistic beliefs. A great amount of myths, which most of them are of “indigenous origin” and many are “derived from the Hindu-Javanese classical literature,” are deeply embedded in Balinese daily life   (Hobart 1996: 137).

Hindu originated epics, the Mahabharata and the Rayamana, are two main sources associated with Balinese traditional cultural development. The stories of these epics provide the people concepts such as their relationship with gods, the caste system existing in their world, and the ethical behaviors they pursue. It is also within the frame of these two epics that the Balinese created their indigenous characters and philosophical thoughts to indicate how to maintain the balance between the universe and the individual.

The Hindu and animistic elements shown in this unique belief system built by the Balinese have interwoven with each other for hundreds of years. They became so intricate that greatly influenced the process of art making and its outcomes, including architecture, sculpture, painting, textile, music, dance, and drama.  Based on the belief that the Balinese distinctive cultural phenomenon is a result of the coexistence of two religious philosophies, Hinduism and animism, I will discuss how specifically this coexistence appears in the performing art of Wayang Kulit, the shadow puppet play in this paper. 

Wayang Kulit-The Shadow Puppet Theatre

Introduction

In Indonesia, the shadow is animistically considered to be a “kind of intermediary between the visible world” and the “unseen realm of the spirit” (Reed 1986: 2). People of the “abangan” culture in traditional Indonesian society who follow the  “ritualistic-polytheistic-magical religious pattern” (Geertz 1960: 268), believe that the souls of their ancestors would be “brought to life as shadows” to give them advice and guide them in a supernatural way. This communication between the dead and alive has led scholars to believe that the wayang kulit originally was set to serve a ritual function (Reed 1986: 2). The earliest evidence is a record discovered in Central Java indicating that an “existence” of wayang performance in 907 AD. The performance was given as a ritual dedication for the gods of the local monastery (Holt 1967: 128).

Not until the 11th century did the royal inscription Prasasti Anak Wungsu in Bali mention a wayang performance (Hobart 1996: 144). This inscription shows that the wayang performance might have reached Bali between the 11th century and the Hindu-Javanese’s exile in the 14th centuries. Consequently, the performance and function of wayang kulit in Bali may have shared most of the significant characteristics the Hindu-Javanese had developed in this art in the past. 

The performance of wayang kulit, both in Java and Bali, consists of several elements. According to Hobart (Hobart 1996: 144), these elements, which are “deeply rooted in myth and poetry,” include the dalang (the puppeteer), the stories, the puppets, the music accompaniment, the stage setting, and the performance itself. During a performance, usually in the evening, the puppets are projected to a white screen, where they are manipulated by the dalang in a flaming light of a coconut-oil lamp (Hobart 1996: 145). The plays, drawn from numerous sources, are generally known stories modified from the episodes of the great Hindu epics, the Mahabharata and the Ramayana (McPhee 1970: 148-149); however, some indigenous folklore created by the Balinese are always included in the episodes. The music ensemble, gender wayang, which provides the accompaniment for the theatre, is never absent from any performance. All these elements of wayang performance interlock closely with each other and have their essential roles to play in order to complete the offering to please their gods and ancestors, as well as to provide entertainment for the people who still live in the world.

These elements have been closely interdependent with each other in the wayang performance; they somehow reflect the communal style of living in the Balinese society, which an individual has his primary position to a village banjar or the temple system.  As a miniature of the cosmos, the wayang kulit implies the order, the harmony, and the balance in the universe.

To study the religious philosophical thoughts, the Hinduism and animism, as well as the interactions between these two components, I will examine the elements that made up a wayang kulit performance, and provide insights of how both components of Hinduism and animism coexist in the performance of wayang kulit, symbolically.

Dalang

         In the performance of wayang kulit, it is through the dalang that the audience is “transported to a world not subject to the conditions of ordinary life” (Reed 1986: 2). Therefore, not merely a puppeteer, the dalang’s multiple roles in both the world of wayang kulit performance and the society of a real life make him indispensable to the Balinese. He may be a priest while practicing the benediction before and after the performance. When he employs various voices to represent the different characters of the puppets and transmit ancestors’ thoughts to the audience, he becomes a shaman or a mediator between human beings and spirits. He must also be a musician in order to direct the gamelan group to accompany the theater. No matter what function he serves, performing, teaching, or practicing the white magic, he must possess knowledge of literature from the Hindu epics and be acquainted with the temple festivals, rites, and Balinese unique calendar. Thus, from the animistic point of view, it is believed that good dalangs are to be “entranced” so that they have “such powers of concentration and strength” to conduct various events in any single performance (Geertz 1960: 269).

Commissioned by sponsors, either the temples or households for special events, dalang, along with four musicians and two assistants always travel around villages to give performances. The sponsors may request a story regarding things they celebrate. However, they seldom know what the dalang will play for them since they all believe that the performance is actually controlled by the gods, and that gods will inspire the dalang through their different ways. One way, which reflects the animistic root of wayang performance, is that the dalang has to test his breath to “help him decide how to perform a story” (Reed 1986: 3). He has to test his breath twice, first as he leaves his house, and then again when he arrives at the sponsor’s place. Reed describes this process:

He exhales sharply, and notices which nostril is most clear.

If the breath from the left nostril is stronger, there will be a lot

of fighting and action in the story; if the breath from the right is more powerful, the story will favor intrigue and philosophy.       (Reed 1986: 3)

However, if there is a strong difference between these two tests, he then has to pay more attention to “other factors.” These may include the dinner conversation he has had with the sponsors as well as other people, and the mood of the audience he has observed, as suggested by Reed (Reed 1986: 4).    

Although most stories of the wayang kulit are based on the Hindu-epics, dalang, who has profound knowledge of both Hindu and Balinese myths and philosophical thoughts, may, according to the context of the special events, compose a play of his own to please the gods and sponsors. Thus, an accomplished dalang is always the one who skillfully composes his own subplots, “while adhering to the mythological framework” of these Hindu epics (Hobart 1996: 145).

At least three languages are used in Balinese wayang kulit. A blend of Sanskrit, and Kawi, the old-Javanese (Brandon 1970: 31), of priests and scholars, is used in narrative passages and is sometimes sung by the main characters (Reed 1986: 5). The purpose of High Balinese is to translate the main characters’ lines. Also, the characters of the lower caste, mostly the clowns, speak the low Balinese to each other. It takes years of practice and experiences so that a dalang can alternate languages of different levels fluently on the stage. In order to keep up this fluency, the capabilities of literary, dramatic skills, and spiritual knowledge are highly demanded in training a dalang.

Play

Lakon, the plot or story of wayang kulit performance, means “the course of event or action” (Miettinen 1992: 82). There are hundreds of lakon in the repertoire of wayang kulit. Based on the Hindu epics-the Mahabharata and the Ramayan , and some other indigenous tales, the lakon serve as guidelines to the performance. The information a dalang may obtain from the lakon includes “lists of scenes and personages” (Miettinen 1992: 82). The descriptions of the action in the actual play, however, are not available from the lakon. It requires a great extent of improvisation and it is always the dalang’s spiritual experiences and knowledge that determines the actual play.

Despite the magic powers of the animistic side, ethical issues, which are permanently rooted in Hindu philosophy, are demonstrated thoroughly in the stories. In a wayang kulit performance, dalang subtly imparts the philosophical thoughts to the audience through the conversation between the characters. For example, the theme of searching for the holy spring in Bimas story[1] [ccc1]  represents humans’ desire for seeking eternal life, immortality, and happiness.

 The insights of Bima’s journey reflect the religious philosophical thoughts that humans tend to look for things everywhere else without realizing that these things are all “hidden in the holy pramana, the inner soul, with them” (Holt 1967: 146).  The primary concern of Hinduism, that only when one reaches his soul, will he be able to communicate with god, is the skeleton of the whole story. Based on this philosophy, the story further explains how a human being can reach his soul. Suppressing the feeling of sense, exercising self-control over one’s sensual desires and other traditional Balinese values in moral and social matters, such as “loyalty and dedication” are deliberately placed in the lakon, and are orally transmitted to the audience through the puppets by the dalang (Lee 1977: 135).

Puppets

The wayang kulit puppets, elaborately made in leather, are the iconographic art works, which follow the rules strictly from the Hindu caste system and the indigenous social manners in Balinese society. Coincidental to the epics and tales, different characters with their unique “social status” and “psychological qualities” are categorized into groups (McPhee 1970: 83).

According to Hobart, six main groups of puppets exist in the wayang kulit. The first, also the highest one is the “celestial beings,” whose higher morality cannot be understood. The second group belongs to the Brahmana, Satria, and Wesia of high caste. They are the main protagonists of the stories and most of them are the warriors and administrators. Characters such as members of the Pandawa and Korawa from the Mahabharata are in this ‘refined’ group.

The Sudra servants, the Parekan or Panasar, make up the third group. They do not actually belong to the epics. Instead, their appearances in the setting illustrate the indigenous elements of the wayang kulit. For example, the most representative servant-Semar, was created on the basis of Balinese’ animistic belief, which they believe that he is the eldest descendant of the greatest god (Geertz 1960: 276). One can easily recognize the differences from the other characters by his awkward and distinctive look.

The fourth group is the ogres, Raksasa, who stand for the wild. They are immoral and always are the supporters of the hostile party. Scenic figures are in the fifth group. The most important figure in this group is the Kayon, the tree of life. It has various symbolic functions in the performance of wayang kulit. The last group includes the “creatures, animals, and chariots” (Hobart 1996: 147-149).

As the dalang is starting the performance, two puppets are set to the left and right of the screen, and make a division for the characters into left and right camps. These two huge figures, which represent “the angry forms of gods,” serve the function of guardians to protect the whole theater and the audiences from the evil spirits. The following puppet to appear on the stage is the kayon. The dalang holds it “to his forehead,” and “mutters an invocation” to practice a benediction for this evening’s performance (Reed 1986: 4). Being closely tied to their rooted animistic thoughts, the Balinese who attend the wayang performance believe that it is through this introductory-ceremony that they will be “safe from all harm at least as long as [the performance] is going on” (Geertz 1960: 268).

Symbolically, the kayon, which means tree in Sanskrit, serves several functions in the wayang kulit performance. It is primarily used to be a curtain, which indicates the “beginning and end of the performance, scene changes, shifts of location, and passage of time” (McPhee 1970: 153). It may also be used to represent wind, fire, water, “mountain, tree, rain, clouds, holy radiance, or a weapon”, according to the story of the actual performance (Reed 1986: 4). Studying the illustrations inside of the kayon, Lee, suggests that the kayon is a tree of life, which represents the world of nature created by god from the point of Hinduism. Through the different creatures existing in the leaf-shaped figure, the gods prescribes the distractions and obstacles to perfection for human beings to overcome (Lee 1977: 130).

The appearances of the character- puppets, their body- shapes, eye –shapes, headdress, hairstyles, costumes, and the colors all have significant symbolic functions associated with religious and social values in Balinese society as well. The noble hero character, such as Arjuna of the Pandawa family from the Mahabharata, has almond-shaped eyes and a long pointed nose. He must be in a slender shape in order to meet the “Javanese hero ideal of utmost beauty” (Miettinen 1992: 84). Most importantly, the noble hero must always look downwards to show his purity, self-control, and humility. Contrarily, the members of Korawa family and the ogres often have round, bulb-shaped eyes and upward-pointed noses to represent their wildness and greedy nature.

            The servant clowns, the Parekan or Panasar, of local- myth origins are neither the noble heroes nor the ogres. Most of them are fat, short-legged, flat- nosed, and with almond-shape eyes. The unique figure of the clowns is associated with the roles they play in the stories. As servants to assist the noble heroes, the clowns must be intelligent in many aspects; therefore, they deserve to have the wise eye-shape as their

masters have. Moreover, the use of local languages (high and low Balinese) to translate the passages of the main characters reminds the audience of clowns’ indigenous origins. The body shape, hairstyle, and movements may consider the representations of the friendly Balinese figures.

Music

The theater music, accompanied by a gamelan ensemble, is called gender wayang. Usually, there are four musicians playing the ten-key, slendro-tuned genders in this group. It is required for them to master the great technical skills on gender so that they may produce the sophisticated music and have a close cooperation with the dalang during the performance. Gender wayang is also multifunctional. For example, it first prepares the audience’s mood when the dalang starts to arrange the stage setting. It then signals the dalang when the audience seems to be ready for the play. The music also announces the entrances, and provides specific compositions according to different situations.

In addition to the gamelan music, the dalang sometimes sings special songs, the Suluk, for special events or characters since these songs may indicate the special emotions according to the context. Although most texts of these suluks are in ancient Javanese, which the majority of the audience are not capable of understanding them, the suluks are as important as the gendings that wayang gender produces in the play. The most important function especially lies on the dalang’s attempt to lead the audience to various emotional settings (Geerze 1960: 279). The concept of using songs to set emotion, which borrowed from the idea of Indian rasa, somehow, is also related to the primitive mysterious power since, to the villagers, the texts themselves may have white magic powers, and through the dalang, may protect them from evils.

Symbolically, music in the performance of wayang kulit represents the harmony of the cosmos. Its interrelationship among musicians themselves, between musicians and the dalang, and between the performers (musicians and dalang) and the audiences interweaves closely to demonstrate the highly communal living pattern of the Balinese society, where the individuals, instead of creating conflict, share their common cultural elements. 

Stage Setting

The performance of wayang kulit consists of several interdependent elements to make up a miniature of the universe. All the elements, as mentioned above, realistically and symbolically interact with each other in a very close manner in order to have a successful performance to please the gods and the audiences. The wholeness made up by these elements stands for the cosmic order, which is also demonstrated by the practice of stage setting.

In a performance, the white screen is considered the sky of the world. The banana trunk, which the puppets are placed, represents the earth. The shadow puppets projected from the screen seem to symbolize the human beings in the real world. The oil lamp stands for the sun, and of course, the dalang, who thought to give life to the puppets, becomes the god. 

Ways of Seeking God

The function of wayang kulit

Outward

Wayang kulit is one type of the hundreds offerings in Balinese temple system. With the goals of pleasing gods and soothing the demons, offering has become an art for the Balinese to express their sincere respects to the spirits of good and evil.

            As the stage setting of wayang kulit implies, human beings are part of the world system. The earth they live in is placed in the middle part of a "three-world" structure, which consists of upper, middle, and under divisions (Lansing 1983). Everything in these three worlds has its appropriate position and follows a harmonious order. The gods and ancestors who have the holiest place belong to the upper world, while the demons and evil spirits belong to the under world.

Balinese believe that it is through practicing the “calendrical rituals” (Lansing 1983: 145) and festivals that the gods may be pleased and the balance among these worlds may be maintained. Odalan, the "temple activations" illustrates this unique Balinese phenomenon. The Balinese use the institutions, such as "a village, ward, descent group, and farmer’s association,” to  “gather together to chart their collective course" (Lansing, 1983: 145-146). It is this collective nature that the Balinese explore the art of offering to a great extent, and affirm their connection with the spirits of the unseen worlds.

Inward

The inner nature of wayang kulit function is more associated with the Hindu-Javanese philosophical thoughts.  With a similar requirement for human beings in terms of searching the intimate relationship with gods, Hinduism provides a different approach, which always suggests by the stories of the epics.  According to Hindu beliefs, although the cosmos is a manifestation of the gods, life is not merely the product of gods’ will but a series of reactions, which past actions generate the present, and present actions will impact the future. The Hindu philosophical thoughts, which encourage human beings to seek their personal connections with the gods through ways such as meditation, or self-control, have been re-irritated in the performance of wayang kulit for hundreds of years.

The conflict between the Pendawas and Korawas of the Mahabharata provides numerous sources for the audiences to obtain the experiences regarding purifying their inner souls. Examples from those characters’ suffering from choosing “good or bad, pleasure or pain, love or hate,” and most importantly, “between the animal passion and detached, effortless self-control” are all applicable to the Balinese society (Geertz.1960: 270).

The story of Arjuna from the Bismaparwa of the Mahabharata demonstrates how important this concept of self-control is. When Arjuna is reluctant to fight against enemies who include family and former teachers, Kresha, Arjuna's charioteer, forcefully admonishes him that, "It is unworthy not to fight in war… In an attitude of detachment, he ought to focus solely on his darma, and not be swayed by feelings of sadness or joy" (Hobart 1996: 139).   Darma, which "implies individual and caste duty and virtue as well as ultimate reality," is the overall concept that always imparted by the dalang through the characters from the great Hindu epics.

Conclusion

Within the same realm of pleasing gods and remaining connected with gods, interestingly, the two religious thoughts have a significant difference. This variance, however, does not conflict with each other in the Balinese culture. Instead, it leads to the concept of “dualism” (Hobart 1996: 98), which Balinese take for granted that the world indeed lies between two opposite poles. Like the two antagonistic camps of the wayang kulit stories, the Balinese tend to divide their everyday life experiences according to this polarized manner. The Hinduism, from this point of view, symbolically becomes the inner- self of the human being, and the animistic elements may be the representations of the outward features of personality.

 As a conclusion, this idea may be applied to the art of wayang kulit, including the performance itself, performers, puppets, stories, and stage-settings. It is the Hindu philosophical thoughts that provide the fundamental structure for the wayang kulit, giving the performance its inward essence. For example, the basic story structure, the subtle ethical issues of the characters and their hierarchy, the priest- role of the dalang and his literature knowledge, and the order of stage setting interweave together creating the inner soul of the wayang kulit performance.

However, the animistic elements that richly make this theater alive by supplying the energetic outward characteristics are also indispensable in the wayang performance. A good dalang who are capable of manipulating the puppets, directing the music, singing, alternating various voices and languages on stage, practicing the benediction before and after the performance, and lasting for approximately nine hours without taking any break during the performance, are animistically explained as being possessed by the spirits.  A great number of supernatural stories, which consist of the subplot of the play are also originated from the animistic root. Some indigenous characters, such as the clowns, also track back to their folk animistic tradition.

Although the religious elements of Hinduism and animism have their distinct characters existing in the Balinese society, it is nearly impossible to separate them dichotomously. Traditional Javanese’s belief on  “all religions are good, but none is good for everyone” prepares the “roads” for the mixture of the various religions to serve human beings their spiritual needs (Geertz 1960: 336). It is always during the cultural development, such as art, music, and drama that the religious elements are naturally mingled and then re- appeared in a new face.  I believe that wayang kulit has well demonstrated this phenomenon, which Hinduism and animism have coexisted and served different functions to please their gods as well as entertain the people in Bali. 



[1] Claire Holt, Art in Indonesia: Continuities and Change. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press. 1967, 146-147. Bima is a big, rough, rude, and impatient character of the Mahabharta. Although he is a noble prince, he always speaks the low language no matter whom he talks to. He refused to bow to anyone else because a mystical experience once gave him a direct perception of god of gods, Sang Hyang Widhi. The excerpt talks about his insistence of seeking for the water of life.

 

 


 [ccc1]

Bibliography

 

Brandon, J.R.

        1970     On Thrones of Gold: Three Javanese Shadow Plays. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.                         PN2891B7X

 

Geertz, C.

        1960     The Religious of Java. New York: Free Press of Glencoe. BL2120.J3G42.

 

Hobart, Angela

        1966      The People of Bali. Urs Ramseyer and Albert Leemann (eds.) Cambridge, MA: Blackwell            

                         Publishers Ltd. DS647.B2H581996.

 

Holt, Claire

1967                Art in Indonesia: Continuities and Change. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press. N7325.H6C.2

Lansing, J.S.

        1983         The Three Worlds of Bali. New York: Praeger Publishers.

                        DS647.B2L61983

 

Lee, Khon Choy

        1977         Indonesia Between Myth and Reality. Singapore: Federal Publications.

                        BL 2110.L431X977

 

McPhee, Colin

        1970         “The Balinese Wayang Kulit and Its Music,” in Jane Belo (ed.), Traditional Balinese Culture.        

                        pp.146-197. New York: Columbia University Press. GN653.B3B4X.

 

Miettinen, Jukka O.

        1992         Classical Dance and Theatre in Southeast Asia. New York: Oxford University Press.        

                        PN2860.M5381992.

 

Ornstein, Ruby

        1980        “Indonesia,” in Stanley Sadie (ed.), The New Grove’s Dictionary of Music and Musicians             

                        vol.9. pp.167-220. London: Marxist Press. ML100.N48.

 

Panthou, P

        1986         Bali. Singapore: Time Editions. DS647.B2P3313x1986.

           

Reed, C.L

        1986         “Bima Suarga: A Balinese Play as Performed by Ida Bagus Ngurah.” Asian Theatre     

                           Journal 3(1): 1-33. PN2860.A74X.

 

Sutton, R.A.

 

        1996        “Asia/Indonesia,” in J. Titon (ed.), Worlds of Music: An Introduction to the Music of the 

                        World’s Peoples. ML3545.W671996.

  

©Juiching Wang 2000