English 394
Fall 2000
"Writing (in) Cyberspace"

Project Three
Analyzing Virtual Communities
Computer-mediated communication and the Web make it easier
for people with similar interests (ranging from scholars in specific fields,
to activists, to fringe groups) to communicate with each other about politics,
social issues, hobbies, business and professional concerns, health issues, and
much more.
In this assignment you are to analyze one or more virtual
communities in relation to their construction, representation
and rhetoric. Your task is to write an in-depth analysis of how the community
presents information in the context of knowledge-making. Here you'll want to
concentrate on a virtual community which can enhance your academic and/or professional
pursuits.
There are a number of ways to approach the assignment,
but some basic steps are necessary whatever your particular approach. First,
you will need to locate and join a virtual community. Below you will find a
series of links to some communities;
there are others to choose from. I've
also included links to various discussions
of virtual communities. If you have a particular interest you'd like to pursue,
try to find a community that is focused on your area of interest. If you have
any questions or are having difficulty finding or choosing a community, feel
free to contact me . Once you've chosen
and joined a community, you'll need to become familiar with its workings and
what makes it unique.
Objectives:
- To study a virtual, on-line community
- To become aware of how technology shapes human interactions
and vice versa
- To become aware of the ethical, social and cultural
dynamics of a virtual community
- To become more knowledgeable
about a virtual community which can enhance your academic and/or professional
pursuits
- To learn how virtual communities conduct themselves
with the goal of becoming a more knowledgeable and effective member of virtual
communities
- To develop an analysis of the rhetoric of a particular
virtual community
Please Note: Most of us have heard about hate groups
and other groups with questionable, and sometimes dangerous agendas who dispense
their views over the Internet. We should be aware of such groups, but it may
not be wise to get involved with a "malignant" group for fear of being identified
with their agenda and getting unwanted material or being harassed.
Possible communities include:
How to Investigate:
- Use search engines
to find your resources. Many include searches of newsgroups. Do key word searches
for type of online community you may be interested .
- Decide how many newsgroups, listservs, Web sites, etc.
you will need to investigate to get a fair picture of the community. Too many
may bog you down. Too few may be misleading.
- If possible, interview someone who is a member of the
community via a newsgroup or other medium.
- Look at various mediums of communiction and various
Web sites. A look at one newsgroup or one Web site is not a broad enough sample
to give you an accurate picture.
- Try joining the virtual community--lurk for several
days on various discussion groups, reading posts.
- When you feel comfortable, add your own voice to the
discussion. How are your comments received?
- Once you've become familiar with and a participant in
the community, you can begin to collect the data you'll need to develop an
analysis--four to six pages--of the community.
- Develop an understanding of how the community operates.
- Take notes and include the Internet addresses for the
places you visit so you can return. Keep a bookmark list of the sites you
visit.
Collecting Data
I'd like you to keep a research log detailing your
experiences and observations each time you log onto the community. Be sure
to note the date and time you log on. You might also try to capture a transcript,
save a newsgroup thread, or save the email mesages your receive from the
community's listserv. During and at the end of each on-line session, write
a reflection of what you observed or learned about the community during
the session.
Specific Details
-
Is there a a frequently asked questions (FAQ) file
or message available about for the group? If so, read it carefully. Such
documents often give crucial background information about the purpose of
the group, the list owner, and the rules of participation.
-
Quantitative data including the number of posts during
a given session for a synchronous environment and the number of posts sent
over a given time period (a day or week ) for an asynchronous community.
-
Demographic data including the number of males and
females participating, the race, class, education level and ages of community
members, the number of people subscribed to a listserv,
-
Social dynamics including flame wars, moments of community
building, personalities of the more frequent participants. . . .
-
Rhetorical dynamics including the kinds of language
used--informal, formal, slang, technical jargon, etc.--the kinds of information
shared, the standards of netiquette, etc.
Suggestions for your project:
- Review the assignment to see what report should contain
and suggestions to find the information. Create a title for your paper.
- Give examples to support your points.
- Describe the community as fully as possible
- Define the components of the community such as membership,
purpose, language, behaviors, interaction patterns, etc)
- Analyze how the community works:
- Do they have predominant interests, themes, philosophies
and styles?
- Is there a predominant tone in the correspondence?
- Did you discover any ethical, social, and cultural
issues that are of concern to the community?.
- Do members of the group have their own language--terms
or expressions that are unique to the group?
Remember: You will publish your finsihed project
on your Web page, so consider elements of layout and desogn: title, graphics,
links. If you include graphics, be sure you have
gotten permission to use the graphics you didn't create or are not advertised
as "free." Be sure to cite sources of quotes and paraphrases.
Some Virtual
Communities
Quick Guide to Mooing--mostly
but not entirely applicable to RiverMoo
RiverMoo
HomePage
Yahoo's
Directory of Virtual Cafes
Discussions
of Virtual Communities
Rheingold's
The
Virtual Community
The
Mining Co.'s
Essays on Virtual Communitites
Net Culture
Virtual
Communities: Abort, Retry, Failure?
Amy Bruckman & Mitchel Resnick, "The
MediaMOO Project: Constructionism and Professional Community" (1995)
E_MOO Central
("Dedicated to research and development in MUD and MOO technology")
Don Langham (Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute), "The
Common Place MOO: Orality and Literacy in Virtual Reality" (1994) (Computer-Mediated
Communication Magazine)
MOObasics
* MOO Tip Sheet for Teachers
(Traci Gardner)
The Culture
and Rhetoric of Cyberspace
The
Rhetoric of the Road
Clicksville
Digital
Culture: The Message is the Medium
Escape
Velocity: A Look at Cyberculture
IRC
Chat
Liszt's
IRC Chat
Listserv
Catalist,
the Official Catalog of Listserv
Email
Discussion Groups and Lists
Lizst, the Mailing
List Directory
Listserv
General User's
Guide
Usenet
Lost
in Usenet
Usenet
News Groups
Usenet
- MUDs, MUSHes, MUSEs, MOOs, etc. Directory
Knowledge
Base - What are Usenet newsgroups?
List
of USENET FAQs by Newsgroup
Moos and
Muds
MUDs
and MUDding
Don't
be Cowed by the MOO
A
Beginner's Guide to MOOing
Writings
about MU*s
MUDs
and MOOs
Island
Internet's FAQ
MOO
Central: with information on MOOs and MOOing, and a handout on MOO
Basics.
Basic
Introduction to MOOs
Quick Guide to Mooing--mostly
but not entirely applicable to RiverMoo
Some Moo Lacations:
Netiquette
Netiquette
Home Page
The
Net: User Guidelines and Netiquette, by Arlene Rinaldi
Ms
Netters' Home Page
Netiquette,
by Virginia Shea, Table of Contents and Welcome Page
NetiquetteNetiquette
Primer