Why
Local?
|
|
Modern Agriculture / Food Production |
Most CSA’s |
|
Fossil Fuel Energy Use (depletion of a valuable resource and
contribution to global climate change) |
Several very large, basically corporate farms, ship produce many miles
to a distribution center, where again the produce is shipped to other
markets. Some produce items come from
places on the other side of the world.
Shipping produce often requires refrigeration, adding to fossil fuel
consumption. As Barbara Kingsolver
estimates in Small Wonder transporting 5 cal of strawberry from CA to
NY takes 435 calories of fossil fuel.
And this is just transportation, not including other aspects of
production and packaging. Other
estimates hold that the average meal in the US has traveled 2000 miles. One good example was illustrated on World
News Tonight, in which they were tracking down E. coli in green onions sold
in Taco Bell. The news group
determined that the onions were grown in southern CA, then shipped to the
northeastern US to be washed, and then redistributed to all the Taco
Bells. Thus, Taco Bells in southern
CA were using onions grown nearby, but first shipped across the country to be
washed and then back. |
Locally grown produce is also consumed locally, with minimum time
between the farm and the consumer and minimum refrigeration. This results in a MUCH lower consumption
of energy to get your food to you. |
|
Economics |
This system has been slowly driving smaller family farms into
extinction. As I recall off the top
of my head, the average annual income from family farms in the US is
approximately 5k per year. Most of
the money the consumer pays goes to the companies that put their logo on the
product and advertise it, not the farmer.
Small farms cannot make ends meet.
Suicide rates among small family farmers in the past several decades
have skyrocketed. They find
themselves facing losing the farm that has been in their families for
generations. Large corporate farms
are taking over and they too are not making money on producing food. Instead huge government subsidies are
often the only source of profit. |
For CSA’s, subscription is directly to the farmer. All money the consumer pays for the
products go directly to the farmer.
As such, the farmer can make a living. For most CSA’s, subscription is fairly long term, so the farmer
is assured a decent income regardless of any crop failures. The community shares in any bounty or any
losses. Due to this, some small
family farms are switching to the CSA.
Local food consumption also keeps the money in the local economy
instead of being redistributed to remote lands. |
|
Pesticides |
Typically very intensive use of pesticides. In this country, these are somewhat
regulated, but abuses may occur. When
we import produce from other countries the danger intensifies. Even recently, US companies were (and may
still be) marketing DDT to other, mostly 3rd world countries. This substance has been banned in the US. Many pesticides are not excreted by your body, but rather build
up in your fatty tissues. Organisms
that eat higher on the food chain, tend to get higher concentrations of these
substances. This is one major factor
that caused the endangerment of the Bald Eagle. While experts may say that the effects of these substances on
humans, at typical levels, is unclear, testing the effects of pesticides on
humans is somewhat unethical… thus the relative dangers of pesticide
ingestion are not well known, and could conceivably be quite bad (especially
considering low levels on a single ingested item, may concentrate when many
are eaten). |
Typically not used in most CSA’s, with no possibility for
ingestion by humans or harm to other animals. |
|
Taste |
To illustrate, notice that those so-called vine ripened tomatoes
often seen in the regular supermarket are still on their vines and probably
were sprayed with ethylene gas to turn them red while on those vines, which
for some time had been separated from a living plant. This is just supposition as I am not sure of
this particular case, but it is an example of the kind of processes
used. A lot of supermarket produce is
just tasteless. |
I think I can tell a substantial difference. Just try a fresh organic tomato that
actually ripened on a living plant and picked the day before (or that very
same day even). |
|
Affordability (Money only) |
Although non-organic typical produce can be extremely cheap, it
is artificially so, due to high subsidies.
The externalized costs are much higher. For a good quick overview, check out www.truecostoffood.org. Additionally, I contend that most people
that eat this way buy many processed foods, which are more expensive than
preparing foods from scratch. Also,
organic non-local produce can often be fairly expensive. |
Since the money typically passes directly from you to the farmer,
it is generally quite affordable.
Additionally, since you are doing more cooking from basic ingredients,
you tend to consume less of the expensive, pre-processed foods. It seems to me that at the minimum it is
about the same price, or maybe even cheaper. |
|
Personal Connection |
I recall hearing of a recent survey of children, where a fairly high
percentage believed that produce actually originally came from a grocery
store. They had no conception of how
that food had come to arrive at the grocery store, nor what kinds of foods
typically grow in that region during that season. I contend that few Americans ever really consider the source of
their food or how it came to be on their plates. |
How many people can say they have personally communicated with
the farmer that produces their food?
I can. I know a bit about her,
have seen pictures of the farm, and learned of some of her basic farming
practices. I have been invited to
come by. |
|
Intensity & Sustainability |
Very Intense. Typically
soil is over fertilized with non-sustainable, fossil fuel derived inorganic
fertilizers. Soil is also typically
compacted, destroying soil structure, promoting erosion, and partly inducing
a requirement of additional fertilizer. |
Typically much less intense. |
|
Yield |
Typically a bit higher per unit of man-hours. |
Typically appears a bit lower due to avoidance of inorganic
fertilizers and pesticides. However,
there are some interesting methods of organic farming that can produce high
yields (e.g. Biodynamic).
Additionally, the yield comparisons are typically made per unit of
man-hours, not per area of land.
Local organic agriculture can actually produce much higher total
yields of all relevant products combined per land area, but these farms
typically employ more workers because of their avoidance of large-scale
industrial agricultural techniques, thus making yield per man-hours lower. It is often mentioned that we could not feed the world if we
converted to local, small-scale industrial agriculture. However, our problems of starvation are
not due to a lack of production. We
produce way more than the world needs.
In fact, small-scale local farms are the only thing that can
consistently provide food in these areas of starvation. The problem is all the farms in the areas
are being pressured into large industrial monocultures for global export,
making only a very few very wealthy at the expense of others. |
|
Consumer Effort |
Typically very low, except that if one wishes to reduce pesticide
levels everything must be peeled.
Shopping is required. |
Higher. Picking up your
share can be relatively easy (as with my CSA) or more difficult. Typically no shopping is required. Most of your time and effort is in
CLEANING, prepping, and cooking. There
are some tricks you can pick-up over time which cut down on this. |
|
Other health benefits |
Many people that use this system do not ingest an adequate
quantity of fresh fruits and vegetables every day. |
The plethora of fresh produce greatly encourages you to eat much
more fruits and veggies each day. Fruits and vegetables are important for a
variety of reasons, from enough fiber for a healthy cardiovascular and
digestive system, to the cancer and skin protective antioxidants. |
|
Education and new experiences |
Typically the kinds of produce offered at the supermarket are unchanging
and every item looks the same (usually genetically engineered to be that way,
I recall something like 70% of supermarket produce is GE). |
Encourages you to try new foods with a seemingly endless variety
of heirloom veggies and things you may have never heard of before (e.g.
sorrel or curly endive or beautiful chioga beets). |