A Buddhist Resource Page
When I first encountered Zen Buddhism in the early 70's,
it was difficult to even find books on the topic. That
situation has changed considerably, both with respect to
Zen specifically, and with respect to the wider Buddhist
community of practitioners. Now the problem for the
newcomer is one of sorting through the many resources
available to find sources that are authentic. This page may
be helpful to you in your search. In it, I will offer my
own list of resources consisting of website links, brief
book reviews, links to practice centers, and so forth.
In doing so my own biases will doubtless be revealed; I make
no claim to objectivity or authority. I'm just a guy
with a website and a lot of curiousity.
A good portion of what you will find here is concerned with
the Zen tradition within Buddhism, as that has been my
practice. You will also find references to a variety of
other facets of Buddhism however, along with related topics
such as mindfulness meditation, Advaita, and others.
Take in what interests you, and leave the rest.
Books
The following are some key books on the topic of Zen, listed
roughly in the order in which I encountered them. I've appended
some commentary, along with links to sites that are relevant to
the book.
Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind by Shunryu Suzuki
I acquired a copy of this book in 1972, a year or two after it
was published. It immediately left a deep impression. I can
recall carrying it with me through the woods in Washington state
when I worked as a forest fire fighter. My view at the time
was that one meditated to acquire a certain elevated state of mind.
This book is a nice antidote to that outlook. The book is divided into
three sections: Right Practice, Right Attitude, and Right Understanding.
That sounds terribly doctrinaire, but as you will find if you read
the book, Suzuki was less interested in philosophical distinctions than
in simply helping the reader to practice. His warmth as a teacher
comes across on every page. Suzuki established the
San Francisco Zen Center, along with
the associated Tassajara Zen Mountain Center. He had many students,
some of whom have gone on to found other Zen Centers or write books.
David Chadwick maintains a website
that keeps track of many of the people associated with the SF Zen Center
and with Suzuki. His website contains links to archival material
on Shunryu Suzuki, including a biographical book on Suzuki by Chadwick.
Edward Espe Brown, who is well-known for his Tassajara cookbooks, edited
a further volume of Suzuki's talks titled Not Always So: Practicing
the True Spirit of Zen that is worth reading also. Chadwick edited
his own volume of stories about Suzuki that is now out of print: To
Shine One Corner of the World. This book presents many anecdotes
that reveal Suzuki's teaching style, and why he is revered by so many. It will
be re-issued by Shambala with the new wonderful title: Zen is Right Here
in October 2007.
The Three Pillars of Zen by Philip Kapleau
This book appeared in the United States in 1967. For many Americans who
were first encountering Zen around that time, it had a tremendous
influence. The book contains a variety of material, including
Hakuun Yasutani Roshi's lectures on practice, his commentary on the
koan Mu, transcripts of his private interviews with ten Western
practitioners, and descriptions of the enlightenment experiences
of eight Japanese and Western students (including Kapleau himself).
Also included is Master Bassui's lectures on the one-mind and his
letters to his disciples. It is hard now to describe what it was
like to go from having only vague notions about what Zen practice might
be, to finding and reading this book. Kapleau founded the
Rochester Zen Center in New York State.
You can visit their website for more information about Kapleau and his
students. The book remains a gem; a good portion of the material in the book
cannot be found elsewhere. One word of caution: Don't get too caught up
in those eight enlightenment experiences. Walk on!
Taking the Path of Zen by Robert Aitken
Jump forward to the early 80's now, and this little book appeared
as an introduction for those new to Zen.
Robert Aitken
encountered Zen as a POW during World War II, returning to Japan after the war
to study with Soen Nagakawa Roshi and Yasutani Roshi. The book
remains one of the best introductory books around, but as we all
remain beginners anyway, it really appeals to all. Aitken has
written extensively on Zen. My favorite is his The Gateless Barrier,
which is his translation and commentary on the Mumonkan, a 13th
century collection of koans used by many practitioners. Two other great books
are his Original Dwelling Place and Encouraging Words. Most
recently, a volume appeared that includes new material, along with
reprints of earlier work: The Morning Star. Aitken founded
the Diamond Sangha in Hawaii,
which now has affiliates worldwide. He also was co-founder of the
Buddhist Peace Fellowship,
which is an organization devoted to socially engaged Buddhism.
I have never met Aitken Roshi, but if I did,
I would thank him for his inspiring personal example and his written
guidance. It has been invaluable to me. My current teacher,
John Tarrant, was one of
Aitken Roshi's students. More about John later.
Dropping Ashes on the Buddha edited by Stephen Mitchell
This book contains 100 short chapters by Master Seung Sahn, a Korean Zen Master.
The book appeared in 1976, and I must have acquired a copy then, as I recall
reading it at that time. The chapters represent very direct teaching, as was
Master Seung Sahn's style. He founded the
Kwan Um School of Zen, whose main center is
at the Providence Zen Center. Seung Sahn
wrote several other good books, including Only Don't Know and The Compass of Zen.
He also had many students, some of which have established independent Zen Centers and
have written their own books. Two recent examples are The Wisdom of Solitude by
Jane Dobisz and Don't Know Mind: The Spirit of Korean Zen by Richard
Strobe.
Golden Wind by Eido Shimano Roshi
This book appeared in 1979, and may now be hard to find. It is worth finding however,
as is a second book Points of Departure Zen Buddhism with a Rinzai View by the
same author in 1991. He founded the Zen Studies Society
and the Dai Bosatsu Center in the Catskills of New York State. Eido's talks in the above book
are wonderful, with each talk addressing a koan. Very clear writing. Eido has just recently
published his translation of The Book of Rinzai, which is the collected talks of Master Linji,
founder of the Rinzai school.
Moon in a Dewdrop edited by Kazuaki Tanahashi
The author of this book has edited or written many fine books on Zen, but I mention
this one because its topic is the writings of Eihei Dogen, a 13th century
Japanese Zen master. The translations of Dogen's writings here were among the first to
appear in the United States, and since that time other excellent translations have
appeared. An example is the monumental translation of the Eihei Koroku, Dogen's
Extensive Record edited by Taigen Dan Leighton and Shohaku Okumura.
Many people contributed to this volume. You should also
seek out the four-volume translation of Dogen's Shobogenzo by Gudo Wafu
Nishijima, (see his website).
Dogen Kigen, Mystical Realist by Hee-Jin Kim and How to Raise an Ox
by Francis Dojun Cook are two other books about Dogen that should not be
missed. I first encountered Dogen through the writings of Shunryu Suzuki mentioned earlier.
Dogen has now become the focus of much attention among Zen practitioners, with
entire conferences devoted to his legacy.
Bankei Zen by Peter Haskel
This book contains translations of the record of Bankei, a 17th century
Japanese Zen master who was unusual in many respects. He manifested a unique
approach to teaching that did not rely on any particular technique, but rather
pointed directly to the "unborn buddha mind." Another text on Bankei that is
worth reading is The Unborn: The Life and Teachings of Zen Master Bankei
translated by Norman Waddell.
Appreciate Your Life: The Essense of Zen Practice by Taizan Maezumi Roshi
Taizan Maezumi Roshi founded the Zen Center of Los Angeles
and produced many students, some of whom now have their own Zen centers. Maezumi Roshi was by all
accounts an inspiring teacher, and this book will inspire you. If you like, you may want to also
read Teaching of the Great Mountain edited by Anton Tenkei Coppens, which contains
talks by Maezumi Roshi. I must also mention one of Maezumi's students, Bernie Glassman, who
helped found the Peacemaker Community, an organization
devoted to social action as part of the dharma. You must read Glassman's Bearing Witness,
which is a stunning book that describes Glassman's experiences with the homeless, and with "witnessing"
at Auschwitz. Two other great books by Glassman are Instructions to the Cook, which takes as
inspiration some material by Dogen, and Infinite Circle. If I ever get to meet
Glassman, I will thank him for his inspiring work. Another student of Maezumi Roshi,
Gerry Shishin Wick, recently produced a volume of commentaries on the classic koans in The Book of
Equanimity. These koans go back to the 12th century in China. Finally, I must also mention
yet another Maezumi student, John Daido Loori, who founded the
Mountains and Rivers Order of Zen. Loori Roshi has an
extensive list of publications. I especially like Cave of Tigers and Two Arrows Meeting in Midair,
the latter being about koan study. For a good sense of what the Mountains and Rivers Order is about,
read Eight Gates of Zen. Loori Roshi is a
photographer, and his recent book The Zen of
Creativity is a superb text on the development of creativity within Zen practice, in his case
through photography.
Bring Me the Rhinoceros by John Tarrant
This recent book presents a fresh perspective on koan study, with commentaries
on 14 koans from various sources. John Tarrant is a student of Robert Aitken, as mentioned
earlier, and is the Director of the Pacific Zen Institute.
Koan study is a rather mysterious topic for many Westerners. For most of us, it is not
obvious how scrutiny of the inscrutable can lead to anything but frustration. Read this book,
and you will look at koan study in a new way. John's teaching employs both humor and insight,
always in the midst of life and never separate. You might want to read his earlier book,
The Light Inside the Dark, which does not address traditional koans but does address
the "Genjo" koan. For those of you in the Tempe AZ area, check out the
Desert Lotus Sangha for information on John's talks
and workshops in the area. I'll also mention my friend Sensei James Ford and his
Boundless Way Zen sangha, in the Boston area.
James is another wonderful teacher, and was a Tarrant student.
Koan Collections by Various Authors
While we are on the topic of koans, you may want to investigate several collections of
koans that are now available. The Blue Cliff Record is a collection of 100 koans
that was put together in 12th century China. A translation by Thomas Cleary and
J.C. Cleary is available in hardback, with a forward by Maezumi Roshi. The Mumonkan
is another collection of 48 koans, also from China but a century later. This collection
is also denoted "The Gateless Gate." Good translations of
the collection are available. I like Robert Aitken's translation and commentaries as
noted above, but you
can find other excellent translations, some with commentary, by Koun Yamada,
Katsuki Sekida, and Zenkai Shibayama. A third collection of koans is
known as the Book of Serenity. The 100 koans of this collection were assembled in
Sung China, around the time of the other two collections. Good translations of this
collection are now available. Aside from the translation by the Clearys and the recent
one by Wick mentioned earlier, you might also read the one by Katsuki Sekida.
Dogen put together a set of 300 koans for use in teaching, and the collection is
known as the Shinji Shobogenzo. The only english translation at present seems to
be the one by Gudo Wafu Nishijima. Given the explosion of interest in Dogen, I would expect
to see other translations of this collection in the near future. A fourth collection lies
in the Record of Transmitting the Light, originally by Master Keizan, but a
well-known translation exists by Francis Dojun Cook. The cases in this collection
represent the successive enlightenment experiences across generations from Shakyamuni Buddha
down to Koun Ejo, presented as koans. This collection is more well-known among Soto Zen
practitioners, but appeals to all. Finally, I should mention the
koans collected in Seung Sahn's book The Whole World is a Single Flower. There
are 365 koans in this book, one koan for each day of the year.
The Miracle of Mindfulness by Thich Nhat Hanh
What does one say about a man who was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize by Martin Luther King Jr.?
A buddhist monk from Vietnam, Thich Nhat Hanh's many books express the dharma in language
that any Westerner can understand. He founded the
Community of Mindful Living, along with the Order of
Interbeing. He became known to people in the United States during the Vietnam war, when
he was exiled from his own country for taking a neutral stand in that conflict. His message of
nonviolence has been a consistent theme; go
here
for some of his wisdom in response to the events of 9/11. The above book is a good one, but there
are many good ones and I won't list them all. I particularly like his For a Future to be Possible,
which includes chapters that discuss Thich Nhat Hanh's work and ideas, written by some well-known
buddhists and non-buddhists. This book was recently re-issued in a shorter version. Two new books by Thich
Nhat Hanh are The Art of Power and Nothing to Do, Nowhere to Go, the latter
being commentary on Linji's writings.
Hardcore Zen by Brad Warner
This book is relatively recent, and I like it. Brad lives in Japan; the book tells how he
got there. He is a student of Gudo Wafu Nishijima's, who was mentioned above in connection with Dogen.
Brad doesn't have much patience for cant or hypocrisy in the Zen world, which probably explains why
I liked the book. If you would like to read more, visit his website,
Sit Down and Shut Up. Now Brad has started a
blog site, which is also of interest. He recently
published a book on Dogen's Shobogenzo titled Sit Down and Shut Up.
Start Where You Are by Pema Chödrön
Pema Chödrön was a student of Chögyam Trungpa's and teaches within the Tibetan
tradition, but her teachings really have broad appeal. The above book is concerned with "awakening
the heart", the development of compassion. She has written a number of other
excellent books. I've found all of them to be useful. She is the Director of
Gampo Abbey in Nova Scotia, Canada. She is also
part of the wider Shambala tradition. For information on this
tradition, you could start with Chögyam Trungpa's Shambala: Sacred Path of the Warrior.
Cold Mountain Poems by Han-Shan
OK, this isn't a reference to an expository text, but it is the real thing nevertheless. Han-Shan
was a Tang Dynasty poet and hermit in China. About 300 or so of his poems exist, and you can find
different translations in English. I've read several of these. Two that I like are the ones by
Red Pine and by Gary Snyder. Gary Snyder is a poet himself, of course, and one who
is deeply connected to the buddhist way of life. Red Pine is well-known for his translations of other
texts, such as the Heart Sutra. If you like poetry, you might seek out poets whose work shows
a buddhist influence. The Japanese poet Ryokan is one of my favorites; his work can readily
be found in english translations. Ikkyu is another Japanese favorite; read Crow with
No Mouth.
On Having No Head by Douglas E. Harding
Well, I suppose that this book will never make it into many reference lists on buddhism, but I am
going to put it in mine. It cuts through all the back and forth, the this and that, and gets right
to it. I first encountered it in the early 70's; my paperback copy disappeared long ago. I was in
a bookstore in North Carolina a year or so ago, and was astonished to discover that it had been
reissued, and even expanded. The reissue has the subtitle "Zen and the Rediscovery of the Obvious."
You can now even visit the website for
The Headless Way. Thank you, Mr. Harding,
for relieving our burden. Lose your head, and gain the world!
At Hell's Gate: A Soldier's Journey from War to Peace by Claude Anshin Thomas
This is a searing autobiograhical account of one man's transformation from a warrior without hope
to a compassionate advocate of nonviolence. He entered the buddhist path through an encounter with
Thich Nhat Hanh, and later studied with Bernie Glassman, taking part in many of Glassman's
"witness" events (see Glassman's On Bearing Witness). The book describes his upbringing and
his experiences as a soldier in Vietnam, along with the aftermath of those experiences. It is a
gripping story. He also created the
Zaltho Foundation, a group dedicated to nonviolence.
What Makes You Not a Buddhist by Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse
This is a recent book by a young Tibetan buddhist who heads the Dzongsar Monastery. I had no prior
exposure to his work, but I really liked this book. In it he attempts to distill the essence of
buddhism down to four points: All compounded things are impermanent; all emotions are pain; all things
have no inherent existence; nirvana is beyond concepts.
It is not a dry philosophical text however; the writing is lively and challenging on
every page. He argues for example that anyone who thoroughly adheres to these four points is truly a buddhist,
regardless of outward appearences. I look forward to further written work from this author.
Websites of Interest
Here are a few websites that may help you obtain more information. I list them in no particular
order.
- Tricycle, a quarterly magazine
about all aspects of buddhism. Their website contains useful links.
- Shambala Sun, another buddhist quarterly.
- Buddhadharma, yet another quarterly,
this one being practice oriented.
- DharmaNet's Buddhist InfoWeb.
This is an immense resource of links to groups, practice centers, online archives, and many
other points of interest. You should visit it.
- Lewis Richmond's website. He is the author
of Work as Spiritual Practice and Healing Lazarus, and was a student of Shunryu Suzuki.
- The Berkeley Zen Center, affiliated with
the SF Zen Center. I remember this Center from my stay in Berkeley.
- The Buddhist Studies Web Virtual Library.
This site contains many portals through which you can explore all facets of buddhism on the web.
- Joan Tollifson's website. Read
Bare Bones Meditation and you will want to know more about Joan. Her site contains many links
to interesting Advaita sites.
- The Mt. Baldy Zen Center, which is the home of Joshu
Sasaki Roshi. I visited this Center for a few weeks in 1973. It remains a rigorous training Center in
the Rinzai tradition.
- The Haku-un-ji Zen Center in Tempe, Arizona.
Affiliated with the Mt. Baldy Center.
- The Everyday Zen Foundation, a site for
people working with Zoketsu Norman Fischer.
- Joan Sutherland's Open Source
Project website. She is a co-founder of the Pacific Zen Institute.
- Byron Katie's website for The Work. Not a buddhist
site per se, but she is a catalyst for self-realization. Read her first book Loving What Is.
Then read the most recent A Thousand Names for Joy, which uses the Tao Te Ching as a
template for her writing. A truly great book.
Some sources of buddhist literature on the web:
Back to Main Page.
Last Updated September 25, 2007
Web Page by Roger E. Millsap
Questions? Comments? Send Roger an email here.