Western States Composition
Conference 1998
Writing and Technology: Media, Message, and Meaning
October 23 & 24, Salt Lake City, Utah
Presentation Abstracts
Karen Spear and Carol Smith - Fort Lewis College
Vestiges of expressivism: Why college writing fails
The paper traces the multiple vestiges of expressivism that students
and faculty bring to college writing and argues that expressivism, as an
unexamined epistemological position, undermines the stature and effectiveness
of college writing.
Bonnie Lenore Kyburz - Arizona State University
Ned Lud in the late age of print: Fear and the folk hero in computer-mediated
composition
For many, Ned Lud epitomizes resistance to progress; thus, computer
technologies, emblematic of today's "progress," have been considered
the primary enemy of the "Luddite." However, the history of Ned
Lud reveals that his revolutionary, liberatory actions are more aligned
with progressivist work in computer-mediated composition than ordinarily
assumed. This paper will explore these possibilities in light of Lud's
history and contemporary iterations of "Luddism."
Annette Shumate - Concord College
The virtual spiritual as metaphor in discourse about cyberspace: Speculations
and implications
Discourse about cyberspace frequently employs metaphors grounded in
spirituality, thus implying unique ways of thinking about computer technology,
its potential, and our experience of it. This paper explores possible implications
of viewing cyberspace as "the virtual spiritual" and, from a
mildly technophobic perspective, applies these observations to writing
and teaching.
Klint Hull - Spokane Community College
Recapturing the vital element of live interaction: Pros and cons of
synchronous chat in the on-line classroom
This paper will discuss the set-up and implementation of synchronous
distance chat (Internet Relay Chat) in a recent on-line technical writing
class, and will share results of observations of that class, as well as
case-study data from a similar implementation of IRC in another writing
class.
Lori C. Brodkin - New Mexico State University
Secondary literacy: Technology and discourse in the intercultural workplace
- or - An American in Sweden
How does an American intern working for an international company with
over 20,000 employees worldwide use "secondary literacy" to communicate
with employees in Germany, China, the Middle East, and Mexico? This presentation
will answer this question using the results of a discourse analysis study
of e-mail collected over a 13-week period at Adtranz Corporation in Vasteras,
Sweden.
Jennifer Hardy Williams - University of California,
Irvine
Publishing student writing on the internet and issues of student privacy
Giving students the opportunity to publish their work on the Web can
be used to change the concepts of community and authority in the composition
classroom. However, what happens when student work is published in such
a way that it allows access to any Internet user? This paper will explore
recent teaching experience and reflect on both the pedagogical possibilities
and privacy issues.
Loel Kim Robinson - Carnegie Mellon University
Teacher persona and on-line communication modalities: Students respond
to teacher comments
Thirty-nine freshmen students received on-line teacher comments in
both voice and written modalities and responded to them along cognitive
and socio-emotive dimensions. Significant teacher differences plus student
failure to recognize the same teacher in different modalities suggest that
a teacher's persona can vary dramatically depending on the modality.
Jonathan A. Singer - University of California,
Irvine
The significance of "netspeak" for composition class discussion
lists
This paper will problematize current prevalent attitudes regarding
the "liberating" possibilities of Classroon Discussion Lists
(CDLs) for composition students and will consider the influence of internet
culture and its discourse on students' CDL contributions.
Steve Marti - Arizona State University
What is wrong with this (rhetorical) situation?: Recontextualizing writing
by creating hypertext(s) in the composition classroom
Compared with "creative" writing programs, few composition
programs are taking advantage of the medium of hypertext. One reason for
this is that the decontexualization of the traditional writing classroom
has not negatively affected the "creative" writing classroom
as much as the composition classroom. This paper will argue that creating
hypertext(s) can recontextualize the composition classroom and return a
vitality so critical to successful writing.
Barbara Sitko - Washington State University
How new teachers make instructional decisions about technology
The internet, Web, and the corresponding proliferation of databases
have had a major impact on instruction about research in introductory composition
classes. This paper addresses how teachers make instructional decisions
that involve not only writing and word processing, but also technological
research skills.
Patricia Wojahn - Robert Morris College
Collaborative writing at a distance: Is the media the message, or is
technology transparent?
This paper will discuss results from a study of collaborative writers
randomly assigned to use one of several different types of computer technologies
to communicate. The study focuses on the nature of communication in collaboration
across time and distance, and on the impact of the medium used to communicate.
Rebecca Busker - Arizona State University
Virtual Kairos: Re-thinking electronic bulletin boards
This paper uses the classical notion of kairos to argue for a shift
in thinking about asynchronous dialogic on-line discussions which moves
away from traditional notions of literacy and orality and begins to explore
the unique features of the medium.
Peter Goggin - Arizona State University
Smile when you write that, partner: Flaming as a sociolinguistic lens
on literate practices
This paper will demonstrate that aspects of on-line discourse can be
viewed through sociolinguistic and rhetorical lenses to gain more understanding
and perspective into the overlap/intersection of oral and written communication,
and will argue that study in on-line discourse and non-print literate practices
may provide new lenses for exploring "traditional" print and
oral literate practices.
Maureen Daly Goggin - Arizona State University
Stitching a new strand: Needlework as technology and cross-stitching
samplers as literate practice
This paper contributes to our ongoing, crucial project of better understanding
the complex terrain of literacy by tracing the history of cross-stitch
samplers as a complex literate practice and needlework as a technology.
Elizabeth Hendricks - University of Utah
Writing positions: A post-structuralist critique of competing composition
discourses
A Foucauldian analysis of artifacts from the field of composition identified
four competing and contradictory discursive formations and patterns within
the field. This paper will address how composition discourses construct
"good writers," that is how they define a place for the writer
from which a particular discursive knowledge and meaning makes the most
sense.
Ronald F. Scott - University of Arizona
Escape velocity is a deadly fantasy: Artificial intelligence and subversion
in cyberpunk
This paper will examine the ways that cultural texts from advertising,
literature, film, and television construct the power of knowledge in the
guise of Artificial Intelligence as a means of escaping the body and thereby
perpetuating the split between reason and spirit.
Charise Nahm, Octavio Pimental, Edward Buendia
- University of Utah
The evils of technology: Marginalizing the other
Technology has made great advances over the years, including the internet
network. While the information on the world-wide web is supposedly accessible
to everyone, this panel argues that these information services are mostly
excluded to third world non-English countries, and even to ethnic people
within the first world countries such as the United States.
Laurie George, Maggie McDowell, Larin McLaughlin
- University of Washington
Incendiary rhetoric, (ivory) towering infernos, and the wired classroom
Computer-integrated humanities courses that skirt ivory-tower topics
of safe academic inquiry and address instead incendiary issues of contemporary
culture and technology edge undergraduates into excited and productively
anxious engagement with critical thinking and writing.
Greg Glau, Judith Kish, Patricia Murphy - Arizona
State University
Basic writers and computers: Imagination, empowerment, and politics
This panel will include the discussion of computers in the context
of basic writing classrooms, focusing on three issues: invention practices,
writing anxiety, and political questions within the university hierarchy.
Geoff Baker, Brad Lucas, Shawn Fullmer - University
of Nevada, Reno
Whose time and space is this anyway? Problems in e-mail, ethics, and
teaching
This presentation will cover problems arising from the use of e-mail
in the classroom. What conflicts emerge between and among students and
instructors? Should instructors participate in such discussions? What are
the ethical consequences of using this medium to study student discussions?
Joe Calabrese - University of Nevada, Reno
A hateful web: What students make of internet hategroup sites
When students in a variety of classes such as Introduction to Language,
American Literature and Culture, Minority Experience, and Investigative
Writing encounter the raw fact of racism on the internet, they think, talk,
and write as though something were at stake. The introduction of "unsponsored"
racial material closes the distance between school and life that often
detaches writers from their own work.
Allene Cooper - Arizona State University
Targeting beginning users: Progressive education ideology and the introductory
document production
While technical communication may often seem skills-based and essentialist,
the principles and ideology of progressive education can and should be
applied to technical writing classes. Application of pragmatic philosophical
principles will be demonstrated by describing activities of a document
production course where natural, context-based learning is emphasized.
Elenore Long - Robert Morris College and Pittsburgh
Community Literacy Center
Literacy and technology in an inner-city housing project: Rebuilding
conditions for hope
STRUGGLE is a collaborative, technology-supported writing process.
This paper is grounded in a case study involving residents of Steadford
Dwellings, one of Pittsburgh's Hope 6 Initiatives, a public housing community
undergoing extreme changes. It examines the uses to which community residents
put the STRUGGLE project - and, in particular, its computer-based writing
environment - during this time of transition.
Will Hochman - University of Southern Colorado
Elements of e-mail: A creative learning pedagogy in process
This paper is intended to encourage writing teachers to consider some
of the specific ways e-mail makes learning creative and informative. Discourse
analysis based on research and teaching will be presented to show how teachers
may effectively employ e-mail in their learning processes.
Linn Bekins - University of Utah
Connecting language, literacy, and technology: How user strategies translate
into complex literate acts
This paper will explore the influence of sociocultural and political
relations on electronic literacy and to discuss what it means to be literate
from a sociocultural perspective. A case study of how three individuals
from different disciplines appropriated technology as a tool to meet their
literacy needs will be presented.
Robyn A. Hill - University of Utah
Technology in the foreign language classroom
This paper will examine the progression of the use of technology in
the foreign language classroom. Particular attention will be paid to the
use of computers and the Internet. The paper will conclude with speculation
about new technological advances that may impact language education in
the future.
John-Charles Duffy - University of Utah
Computers and community: Reflections from a Third World village
This paper will describe experiences in helping set up a computer center
in a Third World community to argue that, contrary to claims made by many
composition theorists, computer technology reinforces inequity to a degree
that defies containment.
Richard B. McDonald - Utah Valley State College
Computer discussions: Finding a voice for students, while saving your
own
This paper deals with the usefulness of computers for facilitating
group discussions of content readings within a course. Transcripts of class
computer discussions and listservs will demonstrate the benefits associated
with incorporating computer discussion into one's classroom.
Suchoon Mo - University of Southern Colorado
Economic analysis of the distinction between composition and reading
The assumption that a student is a consumer of educational technologies
is in contradiction to the assumption that education is for production,
not consumption, of knowledges. Scholastic achievement is inhibited in
the consumer oriented market. Implications arising from this analysis will
be discussed.
Peter Caster - Oregon State University
Student writing as literature: Dissolving textual boundaries of author-ity
with the assistance of technology
If the medium is the message, then writing teachers need to take a
critical look at the different media by which they present writing by students
and reading for students. We can integrate computer technology into existing
writing pedagogies to reconstruct distinctions between student and author-ized
writing.
Nichole Evans - Brigham Young University
Mind the gap: The shifting face of audience in the electronic classroom
Publishing on-line greatly affects student perceptions of audience,
causing a shift from formal to more informal academic prose. Specifically,
changes in organization, voice, and grammatical conventions characterize
this informality. This paper examines the rhetoric of publishing on-line,
and ways teachers can address changes in student writing.
Chris Werry - Carnegie Mellon University
Imagined electronic communities: Representations of virtual community
in contemporary business discourse
This paper will discuss ways in which on-line community has been understood
and represented within the discourse of business texts dealing with Internet
commerce. It describes how attempts to construct (and profit from) various
forms of community can be seen in relation to a wider set of tendencies
to structure and order the internet, and addresses how within recent business
texts on-line community has become a way of imagining a utopian frictionless
capitalism.
Tiffany Winman - Arizona State University
The promises and challenges of teaching hypertext in the electronic
composition classroom: Is there a (hyper) text in this class?
This presentation will discuss experiences composing a hypertext project
in a freshman composition course. Students revised first versions considerably
after theorizing the project further and focused on organization and integration
of various types of content to accommodate for multiple reading styles.
Nanci Werner-Burke - Indiana University of Pennsylvania
Underneath the hyper-hoopla: What are students really doing with electronic
communication?
The debate over technology in educational institutions often centers
on theoretical implications and possibilities surrounding computers and
their use. This presentation provides data about what many middle school
and secondary students are actually doing with e-mail, IRC, and hypertext.
Results of a recent survey and interviews are presented, along with discussion
and conclusions.
Richard Hansberger - University of Arizona
Whither on the web?
This presentation will discuss the work students do in creating web
sites that represent their research interests as they explore and write
researched argumentative essays. This kind of hyper-literacy, so to speak,
provides students with an invigorating sense of audience but it also presents
both pedagogical and theoretical problems.
Mary Specker Stone - Arizona State University
On-line literate practices of health consumers: A preliminary case study
of composing processes and rhetorical features
The goal of this preliminary case study is to develop a framework for
investigating on-line health discourse practices, specifically ways to
understand how these practices impact individuals' identities, their sense
of control, the decisions they make about healthcare providers and treatment,
and the meanings they attribute to illness and health experiences.
Charles A. Hill - University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh
Hypertext, argumentation, and dialogue
Despite recent assertions to the contrary, there is a necessarily linear
aspect to most naturally occurring argumentation, and this makes hypertext
an ineffective medium for individual arguments. However, constructive hypertexts
allow for multiple. conflicting voices, and instructors can use these types
of hypertexts to demonstrate to students the dialogic nature of argumentative
discourse.
Ellen Strenski - University of California, Irvine
On-line reading between the lines: Using the creative imagination to
search for and critically evaluate internet information
Librarians and computer scientists are competing in an information
technology land rush to teach critical evaluation of on-line information.
We must conspicuously assert our own professional expertise and responsibility
to teach these new internet survival skills of "quality filtering"
which are nothing new: digital literacy transfers interpretive practices
of reading literary texts to reading on screen.
Shane Borrowman - University of Arizona
Ethics and extremism: Off the web and in the classroom
Students are naturally interested in extremist discourse. Such discourse
is easily found on the web, and it can engage students when brought into
the classroom while still allowing such skills as close reading to be taught.
Extremist discourse also pushes students and instructors into discussions
concerning ethics.
Cindy Nahrwold - New Mexico State University
Evaluation issues in electronic collaborative scholarship
From a descriptive and not a prescriptive standpoint, this presentation
will discuss suggestions for evaluating electronic collaborative scholarship
- suggestions drawn from both nonacademic and academic sources.
Julie Robinson - Arizona State University
Techno-homework: Composition teacher grades Webnotes
College freshmen and computers. A techno-dream brings computer literacy
and a community of writers together in Webnotes. This paper explores the
praises, the pitfalls, and how to avoid obstacles when assigning composition
homework on the World Wide Web.
Gian Pagnucci, William Macauley - Indiana University
of Pennsylvania
Project ETC: A tour of the electronic teaching collaborative
This presentation will be a guided tour of the Project ETC (Electronic
Teaching Collaborative) web site, created to address difficulties in doing
collaborative academic work, discussing its origin, development, and design.
Afterwards, participants will brainstorm collaborative academic projects
for posting at the site.