Multi-Sited
Ethnography Project: Transnational Networks, Grounded in Transportation
By Suzanne Schefcik
The
way in which anthropologists today write ethnographies
is rapidly changing. In previous times, single sited ethnographies
dealing with
larger social orders and macro-constructions were commonplace. Today,
however,
multi-sited ethnographies are becoming more popular. Multi-sited
ethnographies
are, “multiple sites of observation and participation that cross-cut
dichotomies,”
according to George Marcus in his article "Ethnography in of the World System:
the Emergence of a
Multi-Sited Ethnography." Throughout my own travels around
the world,
I have
discovered that transportation is a common theme throughout each
nation. Japan, India
and Egypt
each have different
approaches to public transportation that reflect a
lot
about the society as a whole.
Transportation
really can define a culture in more ways than one. Through
transportation,
governmental practices, social configurations and economical means can
be
distinguished. Every country throughout the world has some sort of
public or
private transportation, each one somewhat different than the other.
Although it
is seemly meaningless to research transportation because it seems
irrelevant to
human life, this topic renders many cultural attributes.
During my
travels in Japan,
I encountered public transportation everywhere I went. The elaborate
train
system made it easy and simple to move about from city to city.
Governmental
funding for the transit obviously was necessary for the project. The
state in
which the government lies, a strong democratic society, can be easily
shown through the technical advances of transit.
In
opposition to Japan,
India’s
public
transportation was all over the place. The contrasts between castes
were eminent
through many different transportation methods including: horses,
camels,
rickshaws, buses and automobiles. Rickshaws provided
transport to a
vast
majority of people. In addition, working conditions of the drivers
remain
terribly low. It is apparent the growing population affects the mass
disorganization of public transport.
The final
country
in which transportation methods affected the society was Egypt.
The
general form of transportation in Giza, Egypt
was via
camels and horses. Although
many villagers and civilians rarely use
these
animals for transport, they are still available for tourists to bring
them to
their destinations. The ways in
which the animals are used, treated and
viewed
reflect on the culture.
Chapter
1 Ding
Dong: Japanese Transit
Chapter
2 Reckless Rickshaws in India
Chapter
3 Egyptian Camels
Conclusion
Throughout
the entire planet, public transportation is eminent; whether it be
walking,
riding a camel or speeding in a rickshaw. “Transnational networks are
grounded
in particular places, even if these places are multiple rather than
singular,
and they have an impact on localities and regions,” wrote Alan Smart in
an
article titled "Participating in the
Global: Transnational Social Networks
and Urban Anthropology." Transportation remains a transnational
network
located throughout multiple sites around the world. Public
transportation helps
one gain insight on governmental practices, social configurations and
economical means. The underlying social constraints are visible when
one takes
the time to evaluate them. In accordance with my own personal
experiences in Japan,
India
and Egypt,
specific examples exist.
|